All of our hard ice cream flavors are homemade on site, made without artificial flavors or colors and are available exclusively at Bailiwick Market & Cafe!
Unfortunately, we cannot guarantee that all flavors are available at all times!
Featured Seasonal Flavors
Festive flavors - Coming soon!
Year-Round Favorites
Availability will vary
Coffee Chip:
- Milkhouse Roastery Coffee infused ice cream with homemade semi-sweet chocolate chips
Dirt Road:
- Chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookie crumbs & a peanut butter swirl
Farm Girl Swirl:
- Milkhouse Roastery Coffee infused ice cream with a homemade fudge swirl
Filthy Rich Chocolate:
- Rich and creamy chocolate ice cream
Iced Caramel Latte:
- Lightly flavored coffee ice cream with roasted espresso beans & a homemade caramel swirl
Just Got Dumped:
- Chocolate ice cream with caramel swirl, chocolate covered potato chips & pretzels from Chocolate Pizza Company, almond toffee, & chocolate cookie crumbs
Lake Effect:
- Toasted coconut ice cream with toasted almonds & a homemade fudge swirl
Maple Walnut:
- Local, pure maple syrup ice cream with toasted walnuts
Milk & Cookies:
- Our Vanilla ice cream with homemade chocolate sandwich cookies
Mint Chocolate Chip:
- Mint ice cream with chunks of homemade semi-sweet chocolate chips
Molasses Crinkle:
- Molasses flavored ice cream with homemade molasses crinkle cookies
Muddy Mint:
- Mint ice cream with homemade brownie chunks
Just Maple:
- Local pure maple syrup ice cream with local maple candy pieces
Peanut Butter Blossom:
- Peanut butter ice cream with a peanut butter & homemade fudge swirl
Peanut Butter Bliss:
- Peanut butter ice cream with homemade peanut butter cookies and chopped Reese's Pieces
Pralines & Cream:
- Caramel ice cream with chunks of pecan pralines & a homemade caramel swirl
Show me the Dough:
- Vanilla ice cream with homemade edible chocolate chip cookie dough
Snickerdoodle:
- Cinnamon ice cream with homemade snickerdoodle cookies
Spotted Cow:
- Vanilla ice cream with homemade semi-sweet chocolate chip chunks
Vanilla:
- Our classic vanilla bean ice cream
Vanilla n Stuff:
- Vanilla ice cream with homemade vanilla sandwich cookies, peanut butter covered pretzels, & peanut butter chips
Out-of-Season
Flavors that will return in the summertime and limited holiday flavors
BLACK RASPBERRY (summer)
A creamy black raspberry ice cream made using freshly picked local black raspberries. Only available while berries are in season.
BLUEBERRY (summer)
Blueberry ice cream made with fresh local blueberries
FUDGE SMUDGE (summer)
Our vanilla with a homemade fudge swirl
GOIN' BANANAS (summer)
Banana ice cream with homemade toasted vanilla wafers
HIGH ON THE HOG (summer)
Local pure maple ice cream with maple candied bacon
LEMON BAR (summer)
Our lemon-flavored vanilla ice cream w/ bits of homemade lemon bar
MAPLE PECAN (summer)
Pure NY maple syrup ice cream w/ pecan pralines
MONKEYING AROUND (summer)
Banana ice cream with a peanut butter swirl and mini chocolate chips
NEED S'MORE COWBELL (summer)
Chocolate w/ toasted graham crackers, chocolate covered marshmallows & graham crackers in a creamy marshmallow swirl (named after the famous SNL skit... check it out here!)
STRAWBERRY (summer)
Strawberry ice cream made with fresh local strawberries
RAD RASPBERRY (summer)
Made w/ local red raspberries and finished w/ dark and white raspberry-flavored chocolate chips
POT O' GOLD (St. Patrick's day)
Butterscotch ice cream with a butterscotch swirl, butterscotch chocolate chips, and a homemade toffee nut crunch
13 CURVES (Halloween)
Our dirt road ice cream with a marshmallow swirl
JACK O LANTERN (Halloween)
Pumpkin ice cream with homemade semi-sweet chocolate chip chunks
PUMPKIN PIE (Halloween)
Pumpkin ice cream with toasted pie crust pieces
REST IN PIECES (Halloween)
Peanut butter ice cream with chopped Reese's Pieces & chocolate covered peanut butter pretzels